
So. If in Flawed Dogs the story deserts its characters and in Dog Days! the character deserts his story, then what about Everything for a Dog, by Ann M. Martin?
Everything is the kind of book I usually steer clear of: a sweet and gentle cover, a dedication to an elderly aunt, the faint whiff of writerly brussel sprouts.* It’s also a companion book to A Dog’s Life, so I’m coming in during the middle of the author’s intent, something that is a bit unfair.
Everything is everything as advertised (sweet, poignant, you’ll thank me for it later), which means over the course of a week I pick up the book and impatiently put it down; pick up, impatiently down and so forth. However, I do finish Everything which is a huge endorsement right there.
Or maybe I should say: it’s a huge endorsement of a story with good writerly bones, because while the story line is certainly well-trodden and brings nothing new to the banquet table of kiddie lit**, the structure of the novel---which alternates the father’s and the son’s story (with a dog acting as the idée fixé )---is well done. The characters inhabit the story and propel the story along; the story reveals the characters more fully: we come to empathize with both Charlie’s dog-refusal and Henry’s dog-yearning; and we rejoice in the end as both Charlie and Henry change and are changing, as both protagonists indeed in a spiritual sense give up everything for a dog.
But huh? No interior illustrations? Everything has two very appealing and beautiful dog characters in Sunny and Bone. Readers of a certain age want to turn the page and see them race around until they fall over in big, golden heaps of doggie smiles. So c’mon, MacMillan. Ann Martin’s one of your brand-name writers---she deserves a couple of well-drawn dogs. Don’t be so stingy next time, okay?***
______________
*I’m-gonna-stand-here-until-you-clean-your-plate-because-it’s-good-for-you-you’ll-thank me-when-you’re-older.
**The Olympian older brother dies, leaving the deeply flawed younger brother alive! A dog dies, shot by an evil hunter! (As a resident of a state where the white-tail deer outnumber the human population two to one, I’d like to point out that not all hunters are the cowardly gits so beloved of kiddie-lit writers these days.) A dog runs afoul of an animal trap! (Gosh, my second dog in-a-trap story this week alone! I'm a lucky reader!) The secondary characters include: The perceptive old farmer! The witch-in-the-scary-house-next-door-who-turns-out-to-have-a-kind-heart old neighbor! The overwhelmed yupper-dom couple with a new baby who give away their rambunctious dog! And (my personal favorite) the librarian mom, a character who lets the write wedge in any number of childhood book classics (Treasure Island! Hardy Boys! All-of-a-Kind Family!) with impunity!
***I hereby certify that where ere she may go, and what ere she may do, my dog character will not tangle with a trap. Come to think of it, both dogs afflicted with trapitis were males, so I will insert the observation that my dog is a girl, thank goodness, and hence smart enough to know the difference between a trap and a hole in the ground. But I do it in a footnote, so it offends the mere handful of folks who actually read footnotes. Do you think MacMillan reads footnotes? Because I’ve got my writerly heart set interior illustrations for my boy-and-his-dog book, baby!